Schizophrenia is a chronic,
devastating brain disorder that is characterized by psychotic symptoms, such as
hallucinations and delusions, and by deficits in normal cognitive, emotional, and social
functioning. Schizophrenia affects approximately one percent of the world's
population,
and onset is most often between 15 and 30 years of age-when
society has a maximal investment in a person's development. Therefore,
schizophrenia represents a serious problem not only in terms of direct costs and lost
productivity but also in terms of lost human potential. Further, patients with
schizophrenia utilize a disproportionate share of medical resources. Patients with
schizophrenia may constitute as much as 10 percent of the totally and
permanently disabled
and a large fraction of the homeless
population.
For the general physician, the medical care of schizophrenic patients presents a
substantial challenge because schizophrenic patients often are unable to supply an
accurate medical history and often have difficulty complying with medical treatment for
such reasons as homelessness and lack of financial support. Because of suicide and
poor access to medical treatment, the mortality of schizophrenic patients is double that
of the general
population.
Schizophrenia: Epidemiology and
genetics
In three well-studied sites in the United States, the lifetime
prevalence of schizophrenia ranged from 0.6 to 1.9 percent of the
population.
Worldwide, despite some pockets of increased prevalence, there is remarkable
cross-cultural consistency in the prevalence of schizophrenia, with a mean
prevalence of approximately one
percent.
On the basis of twin studies and adoption
studies,
a genetic component to
the risk of development of schizophrenia has long been established. In adoption studies,
increased risk of schizophrenia is conferred by biologic rather than adoptive parents;
twin studies reveal a far higher concordance rate in monozygotic twins (40 to 50
percent) than in dizygotic twins (six to 12 percent). Nonetheless, molecular genetic
analyses of schizophrenia over the past decade have failed to produce replicable
linkages to known genetic markers. This situation is similar to that for essentially
all common complex genetic disorders but stands in marked contrast to diseases in which
a single major gene defect causes the disease (i.e., diseases with a mendelian pattern
of transmission). Disease-causing alleles have been identified in several brain
diseases transmitted in mendelian fashion, including Huntington's disease, several forms
of familial Alzheimer's disease, and, most recently, one form of familial Parkinson's
disease. The findings in Alzheimer's disease reflect a degree of genetic complexity
in that different mutations occurring within three separate genes produce early-onset
forms of the disease. However, for schizophrenia, the best available models of
transmission suggest a higher degree of complexity in that the disorder is a result
of both genetic and nongenetic factors, and multiple genes are likely to be involved,
even within a single family. It is possible that genetic vulnerability to schizo phrenia results from multiple genes, each of which make only a small contribution. The
smaller the contribution of any allele, the more difficult it is to detect it. Moreover,
if many genes act together to produce vulnerability to schizophrenia, no single allele
may be required, and thus, different pedigrees may have both shared and unshared
genes contributing to vulnerability.
As illustrated by the maximal concordance rate of 50 percent for monozygotic twins,
nongenetic factors play an important role in converting genetic vulnerability into
illness. Nongenetic factors that predispose to schizophrenia may include stochastic
developmental factors and environmental factors. Possible environmental risk factors that
have been identified by epidemiological means include in utero difficulties, such as
starvation, influenza, and Rh blood group incompatibilities, and perinatal
complications.
Finally, genetic analyses of schizophrenia are hampered by the lack of pathognomonic
features and by the decreased fertility of persons with schizophrenia. For example, in
one study, persons with schizophrenia reproduced at a rate of about one quarter that
of control subjects.
Findings of family studies of schizophrenia are consistent with the possibility that a
subset of genes that predispose to schizophrenia may also predispose to related
forms of psychopathology. Thus, having a first-degree relative with
schizophrenia increases the risk not only of schizophrenia but also of schizotypal
personality disorder, schizoaffective disorder, and perhaps mood disorders with
psychotic features.
Schizophrenia:
Pathophysiology
Schizophrenia is characterized both by gross anatomic pathology and
by microscopic neuropathology of the prefrontal cerebral cortex, the hippocampus,
and related limbic
structures.
In vivo neuroradiological studies and
postmortem brain analyses demonstrate enlargement of the ventricular
system.
Neuroimaging studies are consistent with loss of cortical volume in the
prefrontal cortex and in the region of the
hippocampus.In addition,
magnetic resonance spectroscopy reveals a reduction in concentration of multiple
neuronal markers limited to the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex and the hippocampal
region.
There are, however, neuroimaging studies that have found
abnormalities in the thalamus, a structure that interacts with essentially
all regions of the cerebral cortex and with the
striatum.
As methods of data
normalization for the normal variance in head size and brain architecture are developed,
brain abnormalities associated with schizophrenia should come into sharper focus.
Many quantitative studies of brain morphology have suffered from the wide variations
in normal control populations. One study addressed this problem by using a cohort of 15
monozygotic twin pairs who were discordant for
schizophrenia.
In 14 of the
pairs, the schizophrenic twin had a smaller anterior hippocampus on the left; in 13 of
the pairs, the schizophrenic twin had a smaller anterior hippocampus on the right.
Compared with their normal co-twins, 14 of the twins with schizophrenia had enlarged
left lateral ventricles and 13 had enlarged right lateral ventricles. The third
ventricle was also larger in 13 of the 15 schizophrenic twins. Such differences were not
found in either hippocampal size or ventricular volume in seven sets of monozygotic
twins without schizophrenia who served as control subjects. This study demonstrated an
important role for nongenetic factors in the pathogenesis of schizophrenia, in that
affected and unaffected co-twins showed significant differences in brain morphology
despite being genetically identical.
Whether these gross anatomic abnormalities bear a cause-and-effect relation to the
primary disease process remains unclear. It is significant that ventricular enlargement
can be detected even with new onset of active schizophrenic
symptoms,
because it suggests that the anatomic abnormalities antedate the onset of symptoms of
schizophrenia. Moreover, neither gliosis nor inflammatory cells have been found in
neuropathological
studies,
which rules out an active neurodegenerative
process. Taken together, these data are consistent with a brain lesion that occurs early
in life and acts in conjunction with a genetic predisposition to schizophrenia to
produce symptoms that appear at a later time. The possible causes of the observed
tissue loss are currently the subject of intensive research. Some studies suggest that
the tissue loss results from a disruption of neuronal migration during morphogenesis of
the cerebral
cortex.
Neuropsychological studies and neuroradiological findings also indicate clear
abnormalities of frontal lobe function in schizophrenic patients. Positron emission
tomography (PET) and single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) in schizophrenic
patients have revealed decreased frontal lobe metabolism (so-called hypofrontality)
that is independent of medication
status.
When schizophrenic patients are
given tasks that require frontal lobe activation, they perform poorly. This impaired
performance correlates with the failure of frontal lobe neurons to activate normally in
response to the task.
The prefrontal cortex and the limbic structures implicated by these anatomic and
function studies are richly innervated by dopamine-mediated pathways. This
finding helps explain the efficacy of antipsychotic drugs that act as dopamine
receptor antagonists, although the precise mechanism by which they
alleviate the symptoms of schizophrenia remains unknown.
There are currently five known types of dopamine receptors, designated D1
to D5. Abnormalities in receptor number or function have been
postulated to be associated with symptoms of schizophrenia, but studies to confirm this
belief have been made difficult by the dearth of well-characterized patients who have
never received antipsychotic drugs, which may cause alterations in dopamine receptors.
Most recently, it has been reported that D1 dopamine receptors are decreased
in the prefrontal cortex of drug-naive and drug-free persons with
schizophrenia.
If replicated, this finding is of interest because D1 dopamine
receptors have been shown to play a role in working memory, a form of short-term memory
that is impaired in persons with schizophrenia.
Schizophrenia:
Clinical features
As defined by the diagnostic criteria in the American Psychiatric
Association's fourth edition of the
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders
(DSM-IV), the essential features of schizophrenia are the presence of psychotic
symptoms during some phase of the illness, a long-term course, and deterioration
in functioning.
No combination of symptoms or signs by itself is pathognomonic of schizophrenia; the course
of illness must be taken into account as well [see Differential
Diagnosis, below]. For a diagnosis of schizophrenia, DSM-IV requires a duration of illness of at
least six months and significant functional impairment. However, the long-held belief
that cognitive abilities deteriorate over the course of illness has recently been called
into question. For example, in 34 schizophrenic patients whose IQs were measured as
children and again 19.4 years later, no significant decline in IQ had occurred over the
course of nearly two decades, but both the child and the adult IQ in these patients
were lower than those of the general
population.
Although the six-month
criterion is arbitrary, the requirement of chronicity markedly improves the validity of
the diagnosis, which is determined by the stability of the diagnosis at long-term
follow-up. Few investigators believe that the DSM-IV criteria characterize a
homogeneous diagnostic entity; however, the criteria have proved to be fairly reliable
in clinical use and have permitted clinical researchers to identify somewhat purer
populations for family, diagnostic, treatment, and outcome studies.
DSM-IV describes four subtypes of schizophrenia: catatonic, disorganized, paranoid,
and undifferentiated. These traditional subtypes appear to have little diagnostic
validity; they have only modest stability over
time
and do not remain
consistent within familial
groups.
Psychotic symptoms that characterize schizophrenia include disturbances in perception,
abnormalities in the content of thought, and abnormalities in the form of thought.
Perceptual disturbances consist of hallucinations and illusions. Hallucinations are
false perceptions that occur in the absence of an appropriate stimulus. In schizophrenia,
hallucinations may occur in any sensory modality, but auditory hallucinations (e.g.,
noises, voices, or music) are most common. Illusions differ from hallucinations in
that a sensory stimulus is present but is misinterpreted.
Disturbances of affect commonly occur in schizophrenia. Patients may exhibit
inappropriate affect-that is, an emotion not normally compatible with the person's
expressed thoughts or situation (e.g., laughing hysterically while describing the death
of a parent). Other patients may have profound blunting or flattening of affect-that
is, a marked decrease in responsiveness to other people and to the environment. Apparent
blunting of affect may also be caused by overmedication with antipsychotic drugs or
by an intercurrent depression.
Abnormalities in the content of thought include delusions and ideas of reference.
Delusions are fixed, culturally inappropriate beliefs that the patient holds despite all
reasonable evidence to the contrary. Although characteristic of schizophrenia, biza
rre delusions (e.g., the belief that an outside force is inserting thoughts into one's
mind) neither are required for the
diagnosis31
nor exclude other diagnoses,
such as atypical mania. Nonbizarre delusions include persecutory or paranoid
delusions, delusions of jealousy, and delusions of reference, which are beliefs that ordinary
events have special significance for the individual (e.g., that a song being played
on the radio contains a secret message intended for the patient). Delusions of reference
that are somewhat less strongly held are referred to as ideas of reference. Somatic
delusions occur as symptoms of schizophrenia and generally focus on disease or
abnormality of some body part. Somatic delusions also occur in depression with psychotic
features. Somatic delusions, in the absence of other mental symptoms, are diagnosed as
body dysmorphic disorders and may respond better to serotonin reuptake inhibitors
than to antipsychotic drugs. Grandiose delusions (e.g., a belief that one has special
powers or a special mission) may occur in schizophrenia, although they are more
characteristic of mania.
Abnormalities in the form of thought (also called formal thought disorder) are
cognitive disturbances that manifest themselves as disorganized or illogical
language or reasoning-for example, vague, digressive, or overelaborate speech. The term
tangentiality is applied when questions are answered obliquely in such a way that
over time the answers become progressively less related to the original question.
Loosening of associations is the term used to describe a patient whose speech consists
of ideas that have no discernible connection to one another. In extreme cases of
loosening of associations, the patient's speech may be entirely incoherent and is
sometimes described as word salad. When the connections in a patient's speech are based
on similarities in the sounds of words rather than on their meanings, the speech is
described as having clang associations. Other manifestations of formal thought disorder
include poverty of the content of speech (i.e., speech that conveys little information
even when it is more or less coherent); long latency before responding to questions;
and blocking, in which the flow of speech stops and the person is unable to continue the
train of thought even with cueing. Schizophrenic patients may also be mute at times.
Another symptom of formal thought disorder is impairment of ability to abstract; for
example, when asked to interpret a proverb, schizophrenic patients may be overly
concrete.
The symptoms of schizophrenia are often separated into positive symptoms and negative
symptoms. Positive symptoms are thoughts, perceptions, emotions, and behaviors that are
not present in the normal human population (e.g., hallucinations). Negative symptoms
describe the absence of normal human responses and behaviors (e.g., social withdrawal or
impaired motivation). Most patients with schizophrenia experience both positive and
negative symptoms, but often, negative symptoms prove more disabling than positive
symptoms. Positive symptoms are generally more responsive to antipsychotic medications
than are negative symptoms, although atypical antipsychotic drugs, such as clozapine
and possibly olanzapine, may relieve negative symptoms in a subset of
patients.
Although the course of schizophrenia is variable, the onset is most common in late
adolescence or early adulthood; it rarely occurs later in life. There may be a higher
overall incidence in
males;
females often have a somewhat later onset and a
better prognosis in terms of overall
functioning.
The illness is
characterized by periods of exacerbation of florid psychotic symptoms followed by
remission. Suicide attempts and episodes of depression are common during the course of
schizophrenia.
Social and cognitive functioning usually deteriorate for
several years and then stabilize. Approximately 80 percent of schizophrenic patients
have a poor outcome as measured by frequency and severity of relapses, continuing
symptoms, and overall
functioning.
Differential Diagnosis
Psychotic symptoms, even when florid and bizarre, are not by themselves
diagnostic of schizophrenia, because they may also occur during the course of
mania, depression, and a variety of less well characterized psychotic disorders,
such as schizoaffective disorder. Psychotic symptoms may also occur as a result
of metabolic derangements, structural brain lesions, or other medical conditions
or as a result of drug toxicity.
Whenever a physician is faced with a newly psychotic patient or a patient in relapse, it
is important to rule out drug abuse, drug reactions, and medical illness as the cause of
the psychosis.
A variety of psychiatric disorders may mimic schizophrenia. For example, psychotic
symptoms are common during manic episodes. Although these symptoms are most often
congruent with elevated mood (e.g., grandiose delusions), some patients, especially
adolescents, may have florid psychotic symptoms, such as bizarre delusions (once
thought to be pathognomonic of
schizophrenia).
Some manic patients exhibit
little or no euphoria or are euphoric only early in the manic episode; such patients may
be predominantly irritable, paranoid, and dysphoric and may be misdiagnosed as
schizophrenic or depressed. Because symptoms of these various disorders overlap,
diagnosis must be based on the course of illness (acute onset and episodic course in
mania versus insidious onset and chronic course in schizophrenia) and the presence of
neurovegetative symptoms, such as decreased need for sleep in mania.
Schizoaffective disorder is diagnosed when patients experience a full manic or
depressed syndrome during the course of illness but have psychotic symptoms when the
mood disorder is not prominent. The validity of this diagnosis has long been questioned.
For clinical purposes, the diagnosis of schizoaffective disorder identifies a group
of patients with a worse outcome than most bipolar depressive patients and a better
outcome than most schizophrenic
patients;
patients with schizo
affective disorder are likely to require both antipsychotic therapy and
mood-stabilization therapy.
When patients have psychotic symptoms of less than six months' duration in the absence
of prominent symptoms of mood disorder, they are classified as having schizophreniform
disorder. These patients represent a heterogeneous group; some have atypical pre
sentations of mood disorder, whereas others go on to manifest typical schizophrenia at
follow-up.
Schizophrenia:
Treatment
The treatment of schizophrenia is based on the use of antipsychotic
drugs, the maintenance of a safe, predictable environment, and the application of
supportive psychotherapies aimed at improving social and coping
skills.
In addition, intercurrent medical illnesses, comorbid mental disorders such as depression,
and substance abuse-a common complication of schizophrenia-must be identified and
treated.
The availability of new antipsychotic drugs with reduced liability for causing
extrapyramidal side effects has revolutionized the treatment of schizophrenia.
Conventional or so-called typical antipsychotic drugs, such as haloperidol, continue to
have an important place in the treatment of schizophrenia because of their long track
record of safety and efficacy, but they carry a side-effect burden that limits their use.
Of the atypical antipsychotic drugs, only clozapine appears nearly free of the liability
of causing extrapyramidal side effects and tardive dyskinesia. Clozapine is also
clearly superior to typical antipsychotic drugs in the treatment of both positive and
negative symptoms of schizophrenia;
its use is limited, however, by the
idiosyncratic occurrence of agranulocytosis, which requires weekly blood mon
itoring, and by other side effects, such as sedation and increased risk of seizures.
Newer antipsychotic drugs that are easier to administer than clozapine include risperidone, olanzapine, and two drugs not yet approved by the Food and Drug
Administration, sertindole and quetiapine. Risperidone (4 to 6 mg/ day), olanzapine (10 to
20 mg/day), and sertindole (12 to 24 mg/ day) cause extrapyramidal side effects but
at a significantly lower rate than typical antipsychotic drugs. Whether they have
enhanced efficacy for negative symptoms of schizophrenia is not yet clear, although one
study of olanzapine
suggested that it might. None of these drugs has been
shown to be as effective as clozapine for treatment-refractory patients with
schizophrenia.
Reduction of stress in patients with schizophrenia may increase the interval between
relapses. Patients have higher relapse rates when living with persons who respond
angrily to the patient's symptoms, express doubt about the legitimacy of the illness, or
show low tolerance for the patient's behaviors. Therapies that improve the family's
understanding of patient needs and enhance the patient's social skills improve the
course of the patient's illness.
These therapies, however, are not a
replacement for medication but an adjunct to medication.